Home > Review Articles > Neighborhoods, obesity, and diabetes — a randomized social experiment

Neighborhoods, obesity, and diabetes — a randomized social experiment

Making Education Easy

Authors:
Summary:

This US-based social experiment assessed the association of personal, individual health with the social and economic environments in which people reside. From 1994 through 1998, the Department of Housing and Urban Development randomly assigned 4,498 women with children living in public housing in high-poverty urban census tracts (in which ≥40% of residents had incomes below the federal poverty threshold) to one of three groups: 1,788 received housing vouchers, which were redeemable only if they moved to a higher census income tract, and counselling on moving; 1,312 received unrestricted, traditional vouchers, with no special counselling on moving; the remaining 1,398 (controls) were offered neither of these opportunities. During 2008–2010, the study collected data on health outcomes, including height, weight, and level of glycated haemoglobin (HbA1c). At follow-up, the rates of a body mass index (BMI) of ≥35, a BMI of ≥40, and a glycated haemoglobin level of ≥6.5% were lower in the group receiving the low-poverty vouchers than in the control group, with an absolute difference of 4.61 percentage points, 3.38 percentage points, and 4.31 percentage points, respectively; the between-group differences were not significant.

Comment:
The headlines in the United States, where the study was carried out, read ‘Change your neighbourhood to improve your health’. If only it were that easy! But there are certainly important messages to take from this study. Good urban design across all neighbourhoods should plan for adequate sources of nutritious kai, opportunities and sites for safe physical activity (like paving, parks and playgrounds) and access to medical care (clinics and/or transport), so that benefits to health and wellbeing are enjoyed by all.
Reference: N Engl J Med. 2011;365:1509-19.
Independent commentary by Dr. Matire Hardwood

Dr Matire Harwood (Ngapuhi) has worked in Hauora Māori, primary health and rehabilitation settings as clinician and researcher since graduating from Auckland Medical School in 1994. She also holds positions on a number of boards, committees and advisory groups including the Health Research Council. Matire lives in Auckland with her whānau including partner Haunui and two young children Te Rangiura and Waimarie.

Research Review publications are intended for New Zealand health professionals.

Disclaimer: This publication is not intended as a replacement for regular medical education but to assist in the process. The reviews are a summarised interpretation of the published study and reflect the opinion of the writer rather than those of the research group or scientific journal. It is suggested readers review the full trial data before forming a final conclusion on its merits.

Related Articles

Explore Māori Health Reviews

Dive into our publications and videos content from over 50 areas of medicine including Cardiology, Diabetes, Oncology, Haematology and Psychiatry. 

It looks like you are closest to our Australia site.

Australia
Australia
Find Reviews in Your Clinical Area
Please select your country of practice.
Terms and Conditions

Website terms of use 

By using our website, you agree to follow these terms and conditions. 

 

Privacy policy 

We take your privacy seriously. To understand how we collect, use, and protect your information, please read our Privacy Policy, which is part of these terms. 

 

Copyright and use of website content 

The content of our website is protected by copyright, trademarks, and other legal rights. You can: view, download, or print a single copy of content for your personal or professional use. 

You cannot:  copy, modify, or distribute website content, or use our website content for commercial purposes or in other works without permission. 

 

Links to third-party websites 

The Research Review website may link to third-party websites for your convenience. However: 

We do not endorse or approve their products, services, or actions. 

We are not responsible for their content or how they operate. 

There is no formal partnership between us and third parties unless we clearly state otherwise. 

 

Disclaimer and limitation of liability 

We do our best to keep the information on our website accurate, but we do not guarantee that it is always correct or up to date. 

To the fullest extent allowed by law, we are not responsible for: 

Any loss, damage, or costs you may suffer from using (or being unable to use) our website. 

Any decisions you make based on the information provided. 

Any business losses, such as lost profits, lost data, or business interruptions. 

 

Governing law 

These terms are governed by New Zealand law. If there is a dispute, it must be resolved in a New Zealand court.