A retrospective chart review of repeat admissions to New Zealand hospitals for acute rheumatic fever from 2010 to 2014 found an overall recurrence rate of 7.2%. A total of 65 episodes of recurrent acute rheumatic fever occurred in 60 patients. All patients were of Māori (51%) or Pacific (49%) ethnicity. Median age at recurrence was 21.6 years, with 83% of recurrences occurring after age 15. The risk of recurrence was 4% for children aged <16 years and increased to 16% for patients aged 16–20 years and 25% for adults aged >20 years. A high proportion of recurrences (73%) occurred in Auckland DHBs. The most common major manifestations of recurrence were arthritis and carditis and recurrence was strongly associated with progression of rheumatic heart disease.